trump. However, if you withhold your ace, spades, you cannot get this wrong.
partner can lead a second spade and you In the last deal partner leads the two of
can draw two rounds of trumps. spades against declarer’s 3NT, clearly a
Andrew Kambites In the next deal West leads the three of fourth-highest lead. Declarer plays the
spades. Should East contribute the queen? seven from dummy. Which spade should
IN this article I continue looking at the
theme of whether third hand should play E/W Game. Dealer South.
high. In the first deal West leads the nine ´ J 10 9 N/S Game. Dealer South.
of hearts against 4´. How should you ™ Q6 ´ Q7
defend in the East seat? t AK543 ™ K54
® J63 t A875
´ Q42 ® KJ32
Love All. Dealer South. N
™ A9 ´ K 10 9 4 3
´ QJ82 W E t J 10 8 7 N
™ 10 6 5 ® K 10 5 4 W E t 963
t KJ9 ® 84
´ 76 West North East South
N ™ A842 1´ West North East South
W E t 8763 Pass 2t Pass 2´ 1NT
® 864 Pass 3´ Pass 4´ Pass 3NT
With the ´K-10-9 surrounding dummy’s
West North East South Are you trying to work out what declarer queen, it might seem natural to play the
1NT has? There is nothing to think about. You nine. However, all is not what it seems
Pass 2® Pass 2™ don't know what declarer has but it can here. Declarer has only two spades.
Pass 3NT Pass 4´ never be right to play your queen. You know If his spades are both small, it won’t
All Pass that declarer has no trump losers; however, matter what you do.
your queen may have nuisance value as long If his spades are doubleton ace, then you
West has clearly led from a doubleton. You as you don't waste it. Suppose declarer has: must play the nine.
must withhold your ace of hearts, encour- ´ A K 8 7 6 ™ K 8 3 t 9 2 ® A 7 2. If his spades are doubleton jack, then
aging with the eight, and hope your partner He has nine obvious tricks: five spades, a you must play the king.
quickly regains the lead with the ace or king heart, two diamonds and the ace of clubs. If So, do you have to guess? There are two
of trumps. Now he can lead his second you play the queen of spades at trick one he good reasons for getting it right. The first is
heart for you to take the ace of hearts and can fulfil his contract in two entirely certainly not conclusive: A lead from a four-
give him a ruff. different ways: firstly, he can concede a card spade suit headed by the ace would be
A similar type of play can occur in the heart and ruff a heart in dummy. Secondly more attractive than leading from a four-
trump suit. Imagine declarer is playing in a he can plan to ruff dummy's fifth diamond card spade suit headed by the jack. The
5-3 spade fit. The success of his contract good, using dummy's spades as entries. second is conclusive. Suppose declarer held
depends on him being able to ruff a heart in If you keep your queen of spades you a doubleton ace of spades. Which spade
dummy but he will first have to concede a foil both of these successful methods: if he would he have played from dummy at trick
heart trick to your partner. Maybe your tries to ruff a heart in dummy, you can one? Surely he would have tried dummy’s
partner has found an inspired lead from a overruff with the queen; alternatively he queen in the hope that West held the king.
small doubleton trump. Your trump hold- does not have winning trumps as entries You must play your king at trick one to
ing is ´A-3-2 but you have no outside entry. to dummy’s diamonds. prevent declarer taking an easy trick with
If you grab your ace on the first round you If you ask yourself what possible gain ´J-5 doubleton. Declarer’s hand is:
will never regain the lead to play your last there can be from playing your queen of ´ J 5 ™ A 8 7 t K Q 4 2 ® A 7 6 5. r
36 English Bridge August 2010 www.ebu.co.uk