FEB_08_EB p37 Scerri 14/1/08 3:08 pm Page 33
‘I had to pass after your
HOW often do you see one of your compulsory 2♥ relay,
opponents pondering their action for ♠ A K4 I showed my flat 23-24
some time before eventually passing, but ♥ A J98 points with a rebid of
then the partner of the ‘hesitater’ finds ♦ A 4 2NT.
another bid? ♣ A QJ6 At this point partner
This certainly happens frequently in produced the longest Ed Scerri
many of the clubs in which I play, and it ‘trance’ which I have
can be extremely frustrating, as it effect- witnessed from him (and there have been
ively constitutes taking advantage of un- quite a few), before finally emerging with
authorised information. However, in many a bid of 6♣. might have been influenced by the
cases I believe that this information is I should mention that he is not known hesitation.
absorbed only on a subconscious level, for his optimistic outlook when playing In any case, 7♣ by South became the
and the recipient acts without any intention bridge, so this bid rather took me back, final contract, and this was the full deal:
or even awareness of unethical behaviour. given my club holding, and the fact that I
It is important to be aware that questions, held all the aces!
hesitations, or even body language, may Although I was well aware that partner N/S Game. Dealer North.
convey unauthorised information, and to had hesitated, and that unauthorised ♠AK4
ensure that we do not take advantage of information had been conveyed to me as a ♥AJ98
this information. However, it is possible to result, I felt that if he could bid 6♣ based ♦A4
take this ethical approach to extremes, and only on the knowledge that I held 23-24 ♣AQJ6
it is that aspect with which I am concerned points, then I could certainly bid one ♠ 875 ♠ Q 10 9 6 3 2
in this article. more, as surely I held the perfect hand in ♥ Q 10 7 5
I have often heard people say: ‘I had to support of whatever his 6♣ bid had been ♦ K J 10 9 2 S ♦Q865
pass after your hesitation, partner,” an ap- based on. ♣ 4 ♣5
proach which, whilst proving commend- The long hesitation could certainly be ♠J
able ethical standards, is sometimes mis- said to have suggested to me an alternative ♥K42
placed given the nature of the situation. If action (alternative to passing), however I ♦73
you have a clear bid, then partner’s actions ‘had my bid’ and so did not allow the ♣ K 10 9 8 7 3 2
should not prevent you from making it. If hesitation to prevent me from making it.
opponents feel that it is not a clear bid then Our opponents, who were relatively in-
they are entitled to ask for a director’s experienced, expressed surprise that I had As can be seen, my partner had taken a
ruling, but if you have your bid then go bid again, believing that partner’s ‘break in rosy view of this hand in bidding 6♣ (I
ahead and make it! tempo’ should silence me. However, the expected another king or queen, or perhaps
This deal came up in the Teams Qualifier director soon confirmed that I could another club), and now found himself in a
at the EBU Autumn Congress in Bourne- indeed bid, but that opponents had the grand slam, which fortuitously came in
mouth. As North I held the hand at the right to call him back for a ruling if they when the heart finesse succeeded.
top of the next column, and opened a felt that my hand did not clearly warrant Our opponents, although not deliriously
Benji 2♦, and over partner’s (almost) another bid, and therefore my choice happy with the outcome, did not bother
recalling the director as they appreciated
that my decision to bid the grand had not
PETERBOROUGH BRIDGE CLUB CHRISTMAS CAKE been influenced by partner’s break in
tempo. In fact, one of them said that in the
A masterpiece of icing by Jurdy Brewer!
same situation, he too would have liked to
The ‘Lapland Bridge Club Xmas Party Rules’ read:
bid 7♣ after hearing 6♣ from South, but
1. Be NICE – it’s Christmas! would have felt unable to do so because of
2. No gleeful OH-OH-OHs (Santa)
3. No hesitating (Mrs Santa)
The moral of the story, therefore, is that
4. No cheating (Elves)
5. No talking loudly about the hands (Dancer whilst you should avoid making marginal
and Prancer bids after hesitations, you should not be
6. No getting cake crumbs on the cards afraid of making clear-cut bids in the same
7. Don’t complain if it’s too hot – you might be circumstances.
on the next sleigh run!! If you are sure that you have your bid,
then make it regardless!
www.ebu.co.uk February 2008 English Bridge 33