OCT_EB_p21 Scerri 18/9/07 11:19 am Page 21
‘When in doubt, bid
one more’ – or do you?
MANY of the old maxims in bridge, such as When 6♣ is making you will concede
‘Second hand plays low, third hand plays 1370. In order to show a profit, therefore,
high’ and ‘always cover an honour with an you can afford to be up to four off (-1100)
honour’ are based on sound principles, and and five off will only lose one IMP (-1400).
although they should not be followed From an offensive viewpoint, the auction Ed Scerri
blindly, they are certainly useful guidelines has sounded rather better. You will have no
for the inexperienced player. What about heart loser, probably no trump loser, and it
the adage ‘when in doubt, bid one more’? Is is likely that partner is short in clubs. Even
this philosophy built on concrete founda- if partner has the worst (likely) holding of tempt to play in 6♣, whilst doomed to
tions, or is it just a mythical justification for four small spades and a doubleton club, you failure at the cost of 500 (East may well
the Over-bidders’ Union? will still be unlucky to lose more than five double), would in fact have been a very
Competitive bidding decisions (parti- tricks (-1100) if you play in 6♦ doubled. good result for North-South.
cularly at high level) are very difficult to So where does all this leave you? Having A somewhat comical result, but given the
judge, and quite often there is a degree of established that when 6♣ is making, then information available, the reasoning behind
guesswork involved, as illustrated by the it is right to sacrifice in 6♦, are you any West’s decision to bid on was quite correct
following deal taken from the Swiss Teams closer to a decision? Should you ‘when in and gives a useful insight into the thought
event at the Peebles Gold Cup Congress. At doubt, bid one more,’ or will you take your process (or judgement) of an expert player.
Game All, you (West) hold: chances defending the opponents’ slam?
Please make your decision now. Conclusions
RHO opens with a
♠J742 Benjamin-style 2♣ All is revealed! So when should you sacrifice, when should
♥— (eight playing tricks you accept the ‘push’ from opponents and
♦AK7653 in any suit or a flat When this sequence occurred at the table, bid on, or when should you double them?
♣ 10 5 2 21-22) and you over- West (an expert player) trusted the bidding, These decisions are crucial, and especially
call with 2♦ which and following the reasoning above, took the so when playing teams with a large number
partner raises to 3♦. sacrifice in 6♦ (duly doubled by South). of IMPs at stake.
Then something unexpected happens: He was in for a big surprise, as both When the decision is not clear-cut, it
South and East had totally misrepresented might be worth considering that, in the
West North East South their holdings! This was the full deal: same way as the other popular sayings in
2♣ bridge, ‘when in doubt bid one more’ is
2♦ Pass 3♦ 6♣ based on sound reasons, although perhaps
? Game All. Dealer South. on this occasion not so much relating to
♠83 the mechanics of the game, but rather on
It seems that South’s eight playing tricks ♥J9862 the fallibility of the participants.
have rapidly grown to twelve! ♦84 It is obvious to state that declarer has a
Although you are not familiar with your ♣9876 great advantage over defenders as he can
opponents, the previous five boards played ♠ J742 ♠KQ965 control both his own hand, and dummy,
against them have not given you any reason ♥ — W E
♥ Q 10 7 3 and can therefore pursue whichever plan
to believe that South is demented, so you ♦ AK7653 S ♦ Q J 10 2 of action he decides on, without interfe-
must treat this bid seriously. ♣ 10 5 2 ♣— rence. Defenders, on the other hand, must
You must now decide what to do. ♠ A 10 try to coordinate their efforts, and work in
From the defensive point of view, the fact ♥AK54 conjunction with each other. This is clearly
that partner has supported diamonds is not ♦9 far more prone to error.
good, as it means that South may be void ♣AKQJ43 One could also look at it from the point
(South’s jump to 6♣ reinforces this asser- of view that there are two defenders who
tion), in which case your hand may hold no can ‘get it wrong’, whereas there is only one
defensive tricks at all. Your holding in clubs As you can see, South’s optimism was declarer, so the defenders are twice as likely
suggests that declarer will lose no trump surpassed only by East’s pessimism, and it to mess up.
tricks, so do you think that partner will take is fair to say that neither of them had If one accepts these assertions, then it
two tricks in the major suits to defeat the described their hands particularly well. must be wise to ‘bid one more’ when faced
contract? If the answer is no, then you must The upshot was that the ‘sacrifice’ contract with a tight bidding decision, but as always,
consider sacrificing in 6♦. of 6♦ was unbeatable, and South’s at- the final decision depends on judgement.
www.ebu.co.uk October 2007 English Bridge 21