AUG_08_EB_p27 Scerri 16/7/08 9:37 am Page 27
AS a result of the unique way in which diamond trick before the opponents have
match-pointed pairs is scored, the tactics had time to signal to each other, or you
utilised when playing this form of the could just take your four heart tricks and
game should vary considerably from those accept two off. Which should you do?
used in rubber bridge, teams bridge, or In order to decide, you should try to Ed Scerri
Butler-scored pairs. answer the questions above:
Unlike all the other forms of the game, 1. Although your side has a 4-4 heart fit
the success or failure of the contract playing (where you would be likely to make
MP pairs is of no importance whatsoever. eight tricks), many pairs use a 12-14 This time you, South, are playing in 3NT
The only thing that matters is how many no-trump range, so your auction will and the defence starts with three rounds of
of the other pairs your score will beat. not be uncommon. spades, with your queen winning the third
With that in mind, you must set a target 2. Although the best result for N/S on round. You need to set your target, so start
when seeing dummy, and this will not be this board would be +110 (2♥), the by answering our three questions:
limited to merely ‘making the contract’. par score is very different. Look at 1. You are very far from being in the
In order to arrive at this target, you need what E/W could make in spades. At same contract as everyone else, as any
to ask yourself the following questions: worse they would lose one spade, two sane pair will play in 4♥.
1. Am I in the same contract as ‘the hearts and two diamonds. It is quite 2. The par score for this hand will be
room’? likely that with almost half of the +650 for N/S, as playing in 4♥ you
2. What is the ‘par score’ for this board? points between them, many E/W pairs would have time to draw trumps, and
3. Have I received a normal lead? will compete. then establish the third spade to
Only once you have a clear picture of what 3. The opening lead appears to be quite discard a diamond from dummy.
you are trying to achieve can you proceed normal. 3. The lead is not a relevant factor on
sensibly. Now that you have gone through the mo- this occasion.
Look at this ordinary board, which tions, you can make a sensible decision on You have ten top tricks, and can take the
illustrates how you should be thinking at how to play this hand. You know that the diamond finesse, but if this fails, you may
MP pairs: par score here is N/S minus 110 (from de- be defeated. This should not deter you,
fending 2♠ ). You must try to beat that however, because taking your ten tricks
score, and that means cashing your five will be worth only +630, which will be a
Love All. Dealer South. tricks, rather than trying to steal an extra ‘bottom’ anyway, so you might as well risk
♠75 trick which might result in going at least the contract in a desperate bid to recover
♥AJ64 three off. the situation. If the finesse fails, you will
♦K962 Minus 100 for two off will not be a bad score minus 100 or 200, but this will still
♣872 score, as it will beat all the N/S pairs be the same ‘bottom’ on the score sheet. If,
defending 2♠. Minus 150, however will be however, it succeeds, then you will emerge
a disaster, and is likely to score very poorly. with +660, and a very lucky ‘top’.
S Let us look at another example: The automatic reaction is to try to make
the contract, or to go as few off as possible,
♠ A84 but as can be seen from these examples, at
♥ KQ75 Game All. Dealer South. pairs the essential thing is to set a target
♦ QJ7 ♠J6 before embarking on a line of play.
♣ J 10 4 ♥ Q 10 7 6 3
♣A82 BBC BRIDGE BUILDER/
As South you open 1NT and all pass.
The lead is the six of spades (fourth N COMPANION
highest), won by East’s king of spades; he S If any member has an unwanted
returns the spade jack which you also BBC Bridge Builder/Companion
duck, and then he plays the three of ♠ Q 10 2 please contact
spades. How should you continue? ♥ AK952
Bernard Davies 01376 513073
It is apparent that you have only five top ♦ A K 10
tricks, which means that you will be two ♣ K5
with a view to purchase.
off for minus 100. You could try to sneak a
www.ebu.co.uk August 2008 English Bridge 27